Which Utility ATV? Owners please ring in...

Discussion in 'General (Main)' started by mxracernumber1, Mar 3, 2010.

  1. mxracernumber1 Husqvarna
    A Class

    I have to get another ATV for hunting this year. I am working on some leftover deals at my local dealer. I have narrowed my search to 2. I am having a difficult time deciding between these two machines and here's why.

    Honda Rancher 400 4x4 (manual shift)

    Good stuff:

    *Fuel-Injection
    *1-Year factory warranty
    *Looks like it belongs in this century.
    *420cc engine
    *liquid cooled

    Bad Stuff:

    *Std. swingarm/monoshock rear setup
    *Because of the shock/swingarm setup, only has 6.5" of ground clearance
    *Racks are whimpy, actually more like an afterthought. I need more rack!
    *Has run-of-the-mill AV tires.
    *Rear drum brake

    Yamaha Big Bear 400 4x4 IRS:

    Good Stuff:

    *IRS means independent rear suspension. My current ride has it and there is absolutely no arguing that it's better.
    *IRS allows for a whopping 10.5" of ground clearance.
    *Comes stock with ITP MudLites.
    *Anniversary addition comes with a winch for about $300 more.
    *Huge racks front and back.
    *Sealed wet, rear brake

    Bad Stuff:

    *6-month warranty
    *Looks like it is the next generation in design after Yamaha's fist quads, the YFM-225 series. Really, this thing is sooo 1988.
    *NOT F.I.!!!
    *Engine is only 386cc!!! (not that it's bad. My current mount is a 250
    4x4), but it still isn't a 420cc!!!


    After having a F.I. dual sport (WR-250R), I am VERY hesitant to purchase a carbed ATV. That F.I. makes things so much easier!

    PLEASE HELP. They are about the same price. I wish one was $1K more so it wouldn't be an issue, but they are just too close to declare a clear victor. I'm almost down to flipping a coin!
  2. Wetdog Husqvarna
    AA Class

    Location:
    Tsawwassen, BC
    Might be worth signing up to a quad forum to get their perspective.

    [URL="www.quads.ca"]a local BC forum that has lotsa members

    I know "rhino bob" on there. He has a Polaris Razor side by side with $5K worth of Ivan Stewarts suspension and the thing rails. Not the same category but blah blah blah...... blah blah blah
  3. PALMER84ONE Husqvarna
    AA Class

    Location:
    Silverado, CA.
    Husqvarna Motorcycle:
    08 TE450 THE ROCKET
    Other Motorcycles:
    12 RS520, CRF150F/230F, YZ250
    I ran through all the ins and outs a while ago. Finally picked the Arctic Cat 500 4X4 Auto. What a beast it was. That thing will carry more than any other rig out there, but it was 6 years ago. I'll bet the Cat is still the best.
  4. audible Husqvarna
    B Class

    Location:
    Temecula
    Polaris RZR====== AWESOME. I thought Rhino's and Teryx were nice...not even close. Polaris is the leader right now. It even comes in a four-seater.
  5. mxracernumber1 Husqvarna
    A Class

    You bet it is. I just saw one yesterday. However, I'm not looking for the biggest, baddest swamp buggy. I'm looking for something 4x4, FI, lots of racking, under $6K (or at least in that range) and I want to be able to pick it up and slide it out of a rut if I want to. I don't want one that weighs 700lbs.
  6. ScottyR Husqvarna
    AA Class

    Location:
    Mitchell, ON
    If I was in the market for a new ATV, I would probably buy a Polaris.
  7. letitsnow Husqvarna
    AA Class

    Location:
    mn
    Husqvarna Motorcycle:
    FC250
    Other Motorcycles:
    CBR600F4
    Neither machine will be a bad choice.

    Basically, all utility machines are HEAVY - while on my way to winning the 2008 AMA D23 Utility Class Harescramble Championship, I highsided a Honda Rincon - it landed on me breaking 10 ribs and puncturing a lung. My Rincon was modified/lightened and was probably lighter than the 420...

    Now I race bikes because they are lighter. ;)
  8. switchback Husqvarna
    AA Class

    Location:
    SLC, UT
    Bought a King Quad 750 last fall for under $7000 OTD. Fuel injected, sips gas, good power, independent suspension, proven technology, great value.... Also have a 700.
  9. dartyppyt Husqvarna
    Pro Class

    Location:
    Illinois
    Husqvarna Motorcycle:
    17 TE 150, 82CR 500
    Other Motorcycles:
    82 125,250,430&500 79 390 83 250
    I wish Husky made one! Imagine the old CR500 2 stroke engine in one. The driver side kick start would still work. We can call it the Husky 500 Kickback!
  10. alkrisma Husqvarna
    B Class

    Location:
    New England
    can-am 800 v-twin, you'll LOVE it
  11. EO430WR Husqvarna
    A Class

    Location:
    Eastern Oregon
    Vote #2 on Can-Am, any of them from 400 on up to the 800 Outlanders. Excellent Suspension for a cushy ride, excellent power. I have been around Hondas and Own a Yamaha, neither will compare with the Can-Am. Second choice; Polaris.
  12. hipsterdufus Husqvarna
    A Class

    Location:
    KS
    i vote kawasaki brute force 750i. the Engine Brake Control is amazing